How Trade-In Values Work in Australia
A trade-in occurs when you sell your existing vehicle to a dealership as part of purchasing another car from them. The dealer assesses your current vehicle's value and applies that amount as a credit toward your new purchase, effectively reducing the amount you need to pay or finance.
The trade-in value a dealer offers is typically lower than what you might achieve selling privately. Dealers need to account for reconditioning costs, their profit margin when reselling, and the holding costs of keeping the vehicle on their lot. However, the convenience of a trade-in and the potential tax benefits can make it worthwhile despite the lower price.
In Australia, when you trade in a vehicle, you only pay stamp duty on the difference between the new car's price and your trade-in value. For example, if you are buying a $50,000 car and trading in a vehicle worth $15,000, you pay stamp duty on $35,000 rather than the full purchase price. This saving can be substantial, particularly in states with higher stamp duty rates.
Factors That Determine Your Trade-In Value
Dealers consider numerous factors when assessing your vehicle's trade-in value. Understanding these factors helps you set realistic expectations and identify opportunities to improve your car's worth before trading it in.
Make, Model, and Year: Some brands and models retain value better than others. Japanese manufacturers like Toyota, Mazda, and Honda consistently demonstrate strong resale values in Australia. Popular SUV and ute models often hold their value better than sedans in the current market.
Kilometres Travelled: Odometer reading significantly impacts value. The average Australian drives approximately 13,000 kilometres per year. Vehicles significantly below this average command premiums, while high-kilometre cars see reduced values. Every additional 10,000 kilometres typically reduces value by 3 to 5 percent.
Condition and Presentation: Visible damage, excessive wear, or poor interior condition reduces trade-in offers. Scratches, dents, worn tyres, and stained upholstery all factor into the assessment. Dealers estimate the cost of reconditioning when determining their offer.
Service History: A complete service record demonstrates proper maintenance and reduces the dealer's risk. Vehicles with full logbook service histories from reputable workshops typically receive higher offers than those with gaps or no documented maintenance.
Current Market Demand: Trade-in values fluctuate based on market conditions. When new car supply is limited, used car values increase as buyers turn to the second-hand market. Conversely, when dealers are overstocked with similar vehicles, they offer less for trade-ins.
How Trade-Ins Affect Your Car Finance
Your trade-in value directly impacts how much you need to borrow when financing a new vehicle. A higher trade-in reduces your loan amount, resulting in lower monthly repayments and less total interest paid over the life of the loan.
Consider this example: You are purchasing a $45,000 vehicle and have a car worth $12,000 in trade. Instead of financing $45,000, you only need to borrow $33,000. At 7 percent interest over five years, this difference saves you approximately $1,900 in interest and reduces your monthly repayment by around $240. Use our car finance calculator to see exactly how your trade-in value affects your loan repayments.
Some buyers mistakenly focus solely on getting a high trade-in offer without considering the overall transaction. Dealers may inflate your trade-in value while reducing their discount on the new vehicle, resulting in the same final price. Always negotiate the new car price and trade-in value separately to ensure you are getting genuine value on both fronts.
Strategies to Maximise Your Trade-In Value
Several practical steps can help you achieve the best possible trade-in value for your current vehicle.
Research Your Car's Value First: Before visiting dealers, research your vehicle's market value using resources like Redbook, CarsGuide, and similar online platforms. Check what comparable vehicles are selling for in the private market. This knowledge gives you a baseline for negotiations and helps identify unreasonably low offers.
Present Your Car at Its Best: First impressions matter significantly in trade-in assessments. Thoroughly clean your vehicle inside and out before the appraisal. Remove personal items, vacuum the interior, clean the windows, and consider a professional detail if warranted. A well-presented car suggests careful ownership and can increase offers.
Address Minor Repairs: Fix small issues that create negative impressions without spending more than you will recoup. Replace worn wiper blades, fix chipped windscreens, replace burnt-out globes, and top up fluids. However, do not invest in major repairs unless the return clearly exceeds the cost.
Gather Documentation: Compile your service records, registration papers, spare keys, and any warranty information. Having this documentation ready demonstrates organised ownership and makes the dealer's job easier, potentially improving their offer.
Get Multiple Valuations: Never accept the first trade-in offer without comparison. Visit at least three dealerships for valuations, and consider online car buying services that purchase vehicles directly. Competition between buyers typically improves offers.
Trade-In vs Private Sale: Making the Right Choice
While trade-ins offer convenience, selling privately typically yields higher prices. Understanding the trade-offs helps you decide which approach suits your situation.
Trade-In Advantages: Convenience is the primary benefit. You handle one transaction instead of managing private sale listings, inquiries, and negotiations. The stamp duty saving can be substantial. There is no gap between selling your old car and collecting the new one, meaning you are never without transport. You also avoid the risks of private sales, including scams and failed payments.
Private Sale Advantages: Higher sale price is the main draw, typically 10 to 20 percent more than trade-in offers. You have more control over the sale process and can wait for the right buyer willing to pay your asking price. For desirable vehicles in good condition, the extra money can be significant.
Calculate whether the price difference justifies the extra effort and time. For a car where trade-in is $15,000 and private sale might achieve $17,500, is $2,500 worth the hours spent photographing, listing, responding to inquiries, conducting test drives, and managing the transaction? For some, absolutely. For others, the convenience of trade-in is worth the price difference.
Negotiating Your Trade-In Effectively
Successful trade-in negotiation requires separating the transaction into distinct components. Many buyers make the mistake of focusing on monthly repayments, allowing dealers to manipulate the trade-in value, new car price, and finance terms to achieve the same payment while maximising their profit.
Instead, negotiate the new car price first, as if you had no trade-in. Get the best possible price in writing. Then negotiate your trade-in value separately, armed with your research on market values. Finally, arrange finance, whether through the dealer or a pre-approved loan from another lender.
If a dealer refuses to negotiate on trade-in value, be prepared to walk away. Other dealerships may offer better values, and some online car buying services now compete aggressively for trade-ins, giving you additional negotiating leverage.
Timing Your Trade-In
Market conditions affect trade-in values, and timing your transaction strategically can improve your outcome.
Trade-in values for convertibles and sports cars peak in spring and summer when demand is highest. Four-wheel drives and SUVs often command better prices leading into winter or before school holiday periods when families plan road trips. End of financial year and end of calendar year can create opportunities as dealers seek to meet sales targets and may accept thinner margins.
However, do not let timing concerns override your actual needs. If you need a different vehicle now, the difference between optimal and suboptimal timing is usually modest compared to the overall transaction value. Waiting months for a marginally better trade-in value while paying ongoing costs on a vehicle that no longer suits your needs rarely makes financial sense.
Ready to see how your trade-in affects your loan? Try our car finance calculator to model different scenarios and understand exactly how much you will need to borrow.
Calculate Your Car Loan with Trade-In
Enter your trade-in value to see how it reduces your loan amount and monthly repayments.
Car Finance Calculator Team
Our team of finance experts is dedicated to helping Australians make informed decisions about car loans. We provide accurate, up-to-date information to guide you through your vehicle financing journey.